Discrimination in Insurance: Experience in the United States

Abstract

Health and life insurers may wish to discriminate based on genetic information by classifying people as high risk or unhealthy based on genetic tests that predict future health problems, rather than on diagnosis of current illness. In the USA, the fear of genetic discrimination by insurers is much greater than the reality, especially for health insurance. The economics of health insurance makes it unlikely that health insurers will want to consider purely predictive genetic information, and there are ample legal threats to keep this possibility from materializing, including the 2008 Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act. Empirical studies consistently document the virtual absence of any genetic discrimination by health insurers. Life insurers are more likely to consider results from predictive genetic tests, but this practice currently is not widespread.

Keywords: genetic discrimination; health insurance; life insurance

References

Alper J, Geller LN, Barash CI et al. (1994) Genetic discrimination and screening for hemochromatosis. Journal of Public Health Policy 15: 345–358.

Billings PR, Kohn MA, de Cuevas M et al. (1992) Discrimination as a consequence of genetic testing. American Journal of Human Genetics 50: 476–482.

Diver CS and Cohen JM (2001) Genophobia: what is wrong with genetic discrimination? University of Pennsylvania Law Review 149: 1439–1482.

Geller LN, Alpers JS, Billings PR et al. (1996) Individual, family, and societal dimensions of genetic discrimination: a case study analysis. Science and Engineering Ethics 2: 71–88.

Hall MA, Barton J, Adams P et al. (2007) Genetic screening for iron overload: no evidence of discrimination at 1 year. Journal of Family Practice 56: 829–833.

Hall MA and Rich SS (2001) Genetic privacy laws and patients’ fear of discrimination by health insurers: the view from genetic counselors. Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics: A Journal of the American Society of Law, Medicine and Ethics 28: 245–257.

Hudson KL, Rothenberg KH, Andrews LB, Kahn MJE and Collins FS (1995) Genetic discrimination and health insurance: an urgent need for reform. Science 270: 391–393.

Iuculano CK (1987) AIDS and insurance: the rationale for AIDS‐related testing. Harvard Law Review 100: 1806–1825.

Lapham EV, Kozma C and Weiss JO (1996) Genetic discrimination: perspectives of consumers. Science 274: 621–624.

McEwen J, McCarty K and Reilly PR (1993) A survey of medical directors of life insurance companies concerning use of genetic information. American Journal of Human Genetics 53: 33–45.

Nowlan WJ (2000) Genetic testing debate may be entering a new era. National Underwriter 104(5): 19–21.

Pokorski RJ (1997) Insurance underwriting in the genetic era. American Journal of Human Genetics 60: 205–209.

Pollitz K, Peshkin BN, Bangit E and Lucia K (2007) Genetic discrimination in health insurance: current legal protections and industry practices. Inquiry 44(3): 350–368.

Reilly PR (1999) Genetic discrimination. In: Long C (ed.) Genetic Testing and the Use of Information, pp. 106–133. Washington DC: AEI Press.

Rodriguez‐Bigas MA, Vasen HFA, O'Malley L et al. (1998) Health, life, and disability insurance and hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal cancer. American Journal of Human Genetics 62: 736–737.

Wertz DC (1997) Society and the not‐so‐new genetics: what are we afraid of? Journal of Contemporary Health Law and Policy 13: 299–346.

Wingrove KJ, Norris J, Barton PL and Hagerman R (1996) Experiences and attitudes concerning genetic testing and insurance in a Colorado population: a survey of families diagnosed with fragile X syndrome. American Journal of Medical Genetics 64: 378–381.

Further Reading

Greely HT (2001) Genotype discrimination: the complex case for some legislative protection. University of Pennsylvania Law Review 149: 1483–1505.

Hall MA (1999) Restricting insurers’ use of genetic information: a guide to public policy. North American Actuarial Journal 3: 34–46.

Nowlan WJ (2002) A rational view of insurance and genetic discrimination. Science 297: 195–196.

Contact Editor close
Submit a note to the editor about this article by filling in the form below.

* Required Field

How to Cite close
Hall, Mark A(Mar 2009) Discrimination in Insurance: Experience in the United States. In: eLS. John Wiley & Sons Ltd, Chichester. http://www.els.net [doi: 10.1002/9780470015902.a0005208.pub2]